Skip to content
THE STARTING POINT
Compare agencies using the same business brief, deliverables, ownership terms, and measurement plan. A persuasive pitch is not a substitute for knowing who does the work, what is included, and how you will decide whether the engagement is helping.
Write the brief before asking for proposals
Describe the business problem in operational terms. Do you need more qualified inquiries, a better website, consistent content, or someone to manage advertising? Name the service area, sales process, available assets, and internal capacity. Avoid asking every agency to solve every problem immediately.
A Los Angeles business can hire locally or remotely. If location matters because of shoots or workshops, explain the actual on-site requirement. If the work is remote, prioritize relevant capabilities and communication rather than assuming proximity produces better results.
Normalize what each proposal includes
Create one comparison sheet with strategy, production, implementation, reporting, and support. Mark items as included, optional, or client-owned. Separate ad spend from fees. Ask whether landing pages, photography, software, and revisions are included.
If one agency proposes a broad retainer and another a focused project, ask them to explain the difference in expected work. Do not force unlike offers into a false price comparison. A narrower scope may be exactly right, provided it solves the immediate need.
Ask who will actually deliver
Meet or learn about the people responsible for the account. Ask who handles strategy, design, writing, implementation, and quality review. A small team can be excellent; a large team can be excellent. The relevant question is whether the promised expertise is available to your project.
Review examples with context. Ask which parts the agency completed, what constraints existed, and what evidence supports any results claim. A platform badge can indicate a relationship or qualification, but it does not guarantee outcomes for your account.
Agree on evidence and decisions
Define a reporting cadence and the decisions the report should support. For lead generation, distinguish all inquiries from qualified inquiries and customers. For design work, agree on acceptance criteria, delivery dates, and approval stages.
Ask what happens when performance falls short. A useful answer describes investigation, priorities, and a review process. Be cautious about guaranteed rankings or revenue without a clear basis. Your contract should not rely on a result nobody can control completely.
Protect continuity before you sign
Confirm access to your domain, website, analytics, ad accounts, and creative files. Specify cancellation notice, handoff, and any third-party licenses. Agree on who owns unfinished work and how open tasks are transferred.
Use the checklist to compare two or three serious candidates. Weight the criteria according to your situation; a content-heavy business may value production more than a business needing technical website work. Choose the clearest fit for the next stage, not the most impressive deck.
Compare two offers without guessing
Suppose one proposal includes strategy and monthly reporting while your staff supplies creative. Another includes creative production but fewer strategic workshops. Neither is automatically better. Add the missing work to each comparison and ask who owns it.
Score only criteria you have evidence for. If a provider has not explained reporting or handoff, mark it unanswered rather than assigning an optimistic score. Request clarification before deciding. The goal is a short, defensible decision record: why this scope fits, what it excludes, and what your team must still contribute.
DECISION FRAMEWORK
Make the comparison clear.
| Consideration | Focus | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Included, optional, client-owned | Compare equivalent work |
| Team | Named delivery responsibilities | Know who handles execution |
| Evidence | Relevant work and explained results | Separate claims from proof |
| Continuity | Access, files, cancellation | Avoid an unclear handoff |
PUT IT TO WORK
Your working checklist.
Check each item as you prepare. Download the worksheet to add notes, owners, and deadlines. Entries on this page are temporary.
0 of 6 completed
COMMON QUESTIONS
A few details worth clarifying.
Should I choose the cheapest proposal?
Only after comparing scope, responsibilities, and support. A lower total can reflect less work rather than better value.
Do we need a long contract?
That depends on the work. Ask for a clear initial phase, deliverables, review point, and exit terms that fit the engagement.
Further reading
Google: Do you need an SEO? ↗External references support platform or policy details. The planning frameworks and hypothetical examples are Adnetix editorial guidance, not market benchmarks.
FROM PLANNING TO EXECUTION
Bring us the problem.
We’ll help define the work.
Explore hiring services or learn how we serve Los Angeles.
Talk about your project ↗